In-Depth
The Thin-Client Landscape, Part 1
I wrote an
article exploring the evolution of the thin-client market from its
roots in dumb terminals to an industry that saw massive consolidation
in 2025, when Citrix acquired Unicon to create a vertical
"end-to-end" stack, and IGEL absorbed Stratodesk to
increase its presence in the software-only endpoint space. The
independent thin-client landscape evolved into three distinct camps:
Citrix's closed ecosystem, IGEL's horizontal software layer, and
10ZiG's position, offering both hardware- and software-based
thin-client solutions.
This leaves IT leaders with a choice
between buying into a single vendor's vertical integration or
partnering with a thin-client provider that doesn't require remote
desktop and application lock-in.
In that article,
I focused on the three thin-client companies mentioned above, but the
market for thin clients is far more diverse. Some companies offer
only thin-client hardware, while others offer a combination of
hardware and software. In this article, I provide a broader overview
of players in this marketplace and then offer a set of criteria to
help you decide which to go with.
The reality is
that the larger hardware vendors have not invested much time or
effort in marketing or engineering their proprietary thin-client OSes
and are more than happy to sell devices and have third-party
thin-client OSes installed on them.
Thin-Client Hardware
Below is a list
of the larger thin-client hardware vendors, along with the
software they typically run.
Hardware vendor
|
Native / bundled thin-client OSes
|
Common third-party OSes used on their boxes
|
10ZiG
|
Their own 10ZiG OS (bespoke Ubuntu-based Linux), PeakOS,
and Windows 10/11 IoT Enterprise on x86 thin/zero clients.
|
|
Dell (Wyse)
|
Dell ThinOS, ThinLinux, Dell Hybrid Client
(Ubuntu-based), and Windows 10/11 IoT Enterprise
|
10ZiG RepurpOS, IGEL OS, ThinKiosk
|
HP
|
HP ThinPro (Linux), HP Smart Zero Core, and Windows
10/11 IoT Enterprise.
|
10ZiG RepurpOS, IGEL OS, ThinKiosk
|
Lenovo
|
Windows 10/11 IoT Enterprise and Linux variants on its
thin-client and tiny-PC lines.
|
10ZiG RepurpOS, IGEL OS, ThinKiosk
|
LG (thin-client monitors/endpoints)
|
Embedded Linux-based thin-client firmware; Windows IoT on some
models.
|
10ZiG RepurpOS, IGEL OS
|
Fujitsu
|
Primarily Windows IoT Enterprise and custom Linux builds on its
FUTRO thin clients.
|
10ZiG RepurpOS, IGEL OS
|
Samsung
|
Windows IoT or embedded Linux on thin-client displays, sometimes
sold as VDI-ready monitors.
|
10ZiG RepurpOS, IGEL OS
|
ClearCube, Atrust, Amulet Hotkey, Advantech, VXL, NComputing,
etc.
|
Mix of Windows IoT and Linux-based thin-client firmware,
depending on model and vertical.
|
10ZiG RepurpOS, IGEL OS
|
The chart above
illustrates the contrast in the thin-client market between hardware
manufacturing and operating system standardization. While major OEMs
like Dell and HP do have their own thin-client OS, the pervasive
presence of "Common third-party OSes" like IGEL and 10ZiG,
and to a lesser extent Windows IoT, across nearly every row suggests
that large companies frequently view hardware as a commodity,
often a choice of software. 10ZiG is in a unique position, as unlike
its competitors, whose hardware is commonly wiped and repurposed with
other software, 10ZiG's hardware column is empty of third-party
OSes, implying a tightly integrated appliance model. Conversely,
10ZiG's own "RepurpOS" appears as a standard replacement on
Dell, HP, and Lenovo devices, indicating that 10ZiG is successfully
penetrating competitor fleets with its software while maintaining
exclusivity on its own hardware.
Thin-Client OSes
Years ago, there
were far more hardware-agnostic thin-client operating systems
available, but over the years, the list has been pared down
considerably, as indicated below.
Software / OS vendor
|
Latest line/positioning
|
Typical hardware it runs on
|
10ZiG RepurpOS, NOS, PEAKOS
|
RepurpOS is a proprietary Linux thin-client OS focused on
repurposing existing endpoints (PCs, laptops, third-party thin
clients) into VDI/DaaS/SaaS devices, managed by its free10ZiG
Manager.
|
Runs on most x86 PCs, laptops, and other vendors' thin
clients, as well as 10ZiG's own hardware.
|
IGEL (IGEL OS)
|
IGEL OS is a Linux-based endpoint OS for VDI/DaaS/SaaS.
IGEL is now software-only and no longer sells its own hardware.
|
Designed for generic x86 endpoints and certified on a wide
range of x86 devices.
|
Citrix eLux
|
Citrix eLux OS is a secure, lightweight, hardened Linux
operating system designed for Citrix environments.
|
Designed for generic x86 endpoints.
|
ThinScale (ThinKiosk)
|
ThinKiosk is a Windows application that “locks down”
an existing Windows PC/laptop/thin client into a managed
software-defined thin client; ThinScale also offers Secure Remote
Worker and analytics tools.
|
Runs on any supported Windows x86 desktop, laptop, or thin
client.
|
Other software-only players
|
Several niche or regional tools provide PC-repurposing or kiosk
shells for Citrix/AVD/VMware on top of Windows or Linux; these
are typically hardware-agnostic and sold as software
subscriptions.
|
Usually targeted at existing fleets of corporate PCs, POS
terminals, or kiosk devices where enterprises want VDI access
without buying new hardware.
|
This table
underscores the industry's pivot toward software-defined
endpoints, in which the operating system, rather than the
physical hardware, serves as the primary strategic asset. It reveals
a clear division in technical philosophy: vendors like IGEL, Citrix
(eLux), and 10ZiG utilize Linux-based architectures to completely
replace the underlying OS for maximum security and efficiency,
whereas ThinScale relies on a Windows-based "lockdown"
approach that preserves the underlying Microsoft OS.
A critical point
is the dominance of "hardware agnosticism," with nearly
every vendor targeting generic x86 PCs and laptops; this validates
the market's growing demand to repurpose legacy assets rather than
purchase new, dedicated thin clients. 10ZiG is the only major
independent player bridging both worlds, offering a software-only
repurposing solution (RepurpOS) for third-party devices while still
maintaining its own hardware line, in sharp contrast to IGEL's
pure-software model and Citrix's specialized vertical stack.
Initial Thoughts
In this article,
I expanded my view beyond the recent market consolidation to examine
the broader thin-client marketplace, identifying a diverse mix of
hardware giants like Dell and HP alongside specialized software
players. I found that while hardware manufacturers continue to
produce devices, they have commoditized hardware, often
under-investing in their thin-client operating systems and
leaving the door open for third-party platforms to take over.
When I looked at
the breakdown of hardware and operating systems, there was a distinct
technical separation between vendors replacing the OS with
Linux-based thin clients for security and cost, and those using a
Windows "lockdown" approach, such as ThinScale. 10ZiG
plays a unique role in this ecosystem. Unlike its competitors, whose
hardware is often wiped to run other software, 10ZiG's hardware
remains exclusive to its own OS, yet its "RepurpOS"
software is deployed across devices from different hardware vendors
(Dell, HP, Lenovo, etc.).
In part two of
this article, I will provide a checklist to guide IT leaders through
the thin-client selection process, emphasizing critical factors such
as protocol compatibility, security features, and the importance of
centralized management. I will also look at the difference between
zero clients and thin clients.